Why Do Parents Wait So Long to Start Potty Training?
Several converging factors pushed training later: a shift in pediatric guidance toward child-led readiness, more absorbent diapers that reduce discomfort, busier family schedules, and better understanding of what forced early training can cause. The average completion age moved from ~18 months in the 1950s to ~36 months today — and there are legitimate reasons for that shift.
📑 In This Article
The Full Picture
Pediatric guidance changed dramatically in the 1960s. Before Dr. T. Berry Brazelton's influential work in the 1960s, early training was the norm — often starting before 12 months. Brazelton's research and advocacy shifted the standard toward "child-led" training, waiting for readiness signs rather than starting on a parent-driven schedule. This became the dominant approach taught in pediatric practices and parenting books for the next 60 years.
Disposable diapers changed the calculus. Modern ultra-absorbent disposable diapers are remarkably good at keeping children dry and comfortable. When children don't feel wet or uncomfortable, there's less natural motivation to use the toilet. Older generations used cloth diapers — the discomfort of wetness was a built-in training incentive. That natural pressure largely disappeared with modern disposables.
Family schedules got more complicated. Consistent potty training requires a consistent caregiver applying the same approach every day. As dual-income households became the norm and children spent more time in daycare, maintaining that consistency became harder. Many parents delay starting until they feel they have a sustained window to commit to it — which often means waiting longer than they initially planned.
Early forced training has real downsides. Research has shown that toilet training that starts before a child is developmentally ready can lead to increased accidents, withholding behaviors, constipation, and power struggles that extend training significantly. Parents who've read about this — or experienced it with a first child — are often more cautious with subsequent children.
What the Research Says About Timing
- Average completion age has shifted from ~18 months (1940s–50s) to ~36 months (2000s–present)
- Children who begin training before 24 months take on average 10+ months to complete; those who start after 24 months average 3–4 months
- The AAP recommends looking for readiness signs rather than targeting a specific age
- There is no evidence that later trained children (within normal developmental range) have worse outcomes
When "Waiting" Becomes a Problem
Waiting for readiness is smart. Waiting indefinitely is not. If a child is over 3 and still not showing readiness signs, it's worth talking to a pediatrician — there may be developmental, sensory, or medical factors worth investigating. Most children show readiness signs well before age 3, and actively looking for them (rather than waiting for the child to volunteer) is part of the parent's job.
Benny Bradley's Potty Training Watch
Once you're ready to start: one of the most effective tools for building the toilet routine quickly is a consistent timer system. The watch reminds toddlers on a set schedule with a vibration and light — removing the "did you ask them recently enough?" question entirely.
Buy on Amazon →